Gudrun Is Right or Holger Is Right?

Learn the consequences of your dialogue choices in Assassin's Creed Valhalla's 'Gudrun Is Right or Holger Is Right?' quest. See how Sigurd reacts.

Alright, so you've hit a bit of a tricky spot in the 'Blame and Sail' questline in Assassin's Creed Valhalla. It's the 'Gudrun Is Right or Holger Is Right?' decision, and honestly, the game's telling you upfront: it doesn't really matter which dialogue option you pick here. Seriously, don't sweat this one too much!

Here's the deal: no matter what you say, Sigurd is going to swoop in and take charge. He's got his own idea of justice, and he's going to lay down the law. Sigurd decides that Holger needs to cough up thirty sailcloths to Gudrun. If Holger can't make that payment, Sigurd's solution is exile. Even Gudrun thinks this is a bit much, but Sigurd's not budging.

This is where you get two more dialogue choices, and again, they don't change the outcome of Sigurd's judgement, but they do show Eivor's stance:

• “This judgement is unfair.”: If you go with this, Eivor will voice that Sigurd's ruling is harsh and unjust. Sigurd, however, will get pretty heated, insisting that his word is final and absolute law in Ravensthorpe.
• “I support Sigurd’s judgement.”: Choosing this means Eivor backs Sigurd up, stating that his word is law, regardless of whether Eivor personally agrees with it.

So, while you can express your opinion, Sigurd's decision stands. It's a good example of how Sigurd likes to assert his authority, even when others might disagree. Don't worry about getting this 'wrong' – just pick the dialogue that feels right for Eivor at that moment.