Should you Give Garreth the Fwoopy Feather

Decide whether to give Garreth the Fwoopy Feather in Hogwarts Legacy's Potions Class quest. Learn the consequences and how to brew the Edurus Potion.

Alright, so you've just finished up the Herbology Class quest, and now Professor Sharp's got you in Potions Class. Head over to the Potions Classroom using the Floo Flame in the Library Annex. Professor Sharp's going to give you the rundown on potion-making, and then it's time to get your hands dirty brewing an Edurus Potion. This is your in-class assignment, and it'll unlock the recipe for you to use anytime later!

As you're heading to Professor Sharp's office to grab what you need, you'll run into Garreth Weasley. He's got a little favor to ask – he wants you to snag a Fwooper Feather for him from the office. He figures Professor Sharp won't even notice it's gone, but he's not exactly asking permission, is he?

So, what happens if you give Garreth the Fwooper Feather?

Honestly, it doesn't really change much in the grand scheme of things. If you tell Garreth 'no,' he'll be surprisingly cool about it and figure out another way to cause trouble. If you agree to help, you'll need to grab the Fwooper Feather from a desk in Professor Sharp's office. It's pretty noticeable, big and purple. Once you've got all your ingredients, including that feather, you hand it over to Garreth.

No matter what you decide about the feather, the next step is to brew that Edurus Potion. It's a pretty straightforward menu task: just pick the potion, and if you've got the ingredients, it'll brew automatically. It takes about 30 seconds. After the potion's done, you'll hear a bit of a ruckus – turns out Garreth managed to get his hands on a Fwooper Feather anyway, and things get a little chaotic, but nothing serious.

After all that, you'll need to chat with Professor Sharp. If you helped Garreth stir up trouble, Sharp will probably call you out, but you can smooth things over a bit by owning up to it. Either way, he'll acknowledge your skills, and the quest will wrap up. Don't stress too much about this choice; it doesn't actually impact your relationship with either Garreth or Professor Sharp.

Good news is, from now on, you can use the potion stations in the classroom to brew whatever you need. You'll eventually get a better spot in the Room of Requirement, but having this early option is super handy!