Brothers and Sisters, One and All

Follow this guide to complete the Brothers and Sisters, One and All mission in Red Dead Redemption 2. Includes tips for finding the kid and evading the law.

Alright, so after you wrap up “Help a Brother Out,” you’ll need to advance the game time to the next day. Head over to the church on the north side of Saint Denis. Brother Dorkins will be waiting for you there. As soon as the mission kicks off, this little troublemaker is going to snatch the Sister’s crucifix and bolt. You’ll need to be quick if you’re aiming for that Gold Medal – you’ve only got 19 seconds to catch him!

To nail that Gold Medal, you gotta beeline it. Head down the street, take a left, follow it to the end, and then make a right. Keep heading up that street, and you'll spot the kid. You’ll need to antagonize him a bit to get him to drop the crucifix. He’ll run off, leaving it on the ground.

Here’s the tricky part: Mrs. Downes is going to spot you on the street corner and call the cops. You need to bail north through the alleys, fast, to lose the law. Once you’ve shaken them, you need to get back to Sister Calderon. The best way to do this without running into more trouble is to approach the church from the back. Use the alleys to get to it from the south, then slip into the courtyard. From there, you can just walk right up to Sister Calderon and finish the mission.