Skip to content
We Loved Once and True
Red Dead Redemption 2

We Loved Once and True

Follow our step-by-step guide to complete the 'We Loved Once and True' mission in Red Dead Redemption 2, including tips for earning the Gold Medal.

By ···10 min read·Multi-source verified
1 reading this guide  

Follow our step-by-step guide to complete the 'We Loved Once and True' mission in Red Dead Redemption 2, including tips for earning the Gold Medal.

Alright, so you've gotten a mysterious letter at your camp, huh? That's Arthur's old flame, Mary Linton, reaching out. Time to head over to her place, which is just north of Valentine. Give her a knock, and she'll ask for your help finding her brother, Jamie.

Walkthrough
  1. 1
    Your next stop is a cliff east of Cumberland Forest. Ditch your horse and approach the group of Chelonians gathered there. You'll find Jamie with them. When the Chelonian Master asks you a question, pick “Undecided” and then “Purpose” to keep things peaceful.
  2. 2
    Jamie's not having it though and bolts on his horse! Quickly hop on yours and give chase. Don't worry about catching him; just keep pace. You'll eventually stop after crossing the railway tracks.
  3. 3
    This is where things get interesting. You'll enter a Dead Eye sequence. You need to press and hold the [R2]/[RT] button to fill the circle in the bottom right. This gives you more time in Dead Eye to shoot the gun right out of Jamie's hand.
  4. 4
    Once Jamie calms down, he'll agree to go back to the station with you. Now, if you're aiming for that Gold Medal, you've got to make it back within 2 minutes. Mary will be waiting at the station, so ignore the marker on your map and follow the railway tracks. Gallop the whole way – it's the fastest route.
  5. 5
    When you finally get to the station, head inside. You'll see Mary and Jamie depart on the next train, leaving Arthur to ponder his romantic entanglements once more.
Tips
  • To get the Gold Medal, you need to peacefully convince the Chelonians to let you take Jamie and then return Jamie to Mary within 2 minutes.
  • During the chase, you can't actually catch Jamie. Just focus on staying close.
  • The key to the Gold Medal for the chase is using Dead Eye effectively to shoot Jamie's gun without harming him. Make sure to fill that circle by holding [R2]/[RT].
  • For the return trip to the station, following the railway tracks is your best bet for speed. Keep galloping!
  • Completing the mission earns you money and experience. Achieving the Gold Medal unlocks a special reward.

100% Human-Written. AI Fact-Checked. Community Verified. Learn how AntMag verifies content