T.O.B.Y.

Speak to Toby in Bloodstone. He will tell you he wishes to clean up the city and needs your help with four fetch tasks.

The Mutton of Eternal Hope: Toby needs the mutton of eternal hope from a home on the waterfront. Go to the waterfront and enter the door just to the right of the Tattoo parlour. Go upstairs to the bedroom and steal the mutton from the cupboard directly across from the bedroom door. Return it to Toby.

The Wine of Forgiveness: Exit Toby’s house and turn left. Follow the street until you see a boat propped up against the wall to your right. Look at the house to your left, break down the door, and go upstairs. Loot the cupboard near the baby’s bed for the wine. Return it to Toby.

The Sacred Pie of Kindness: Exit the building and head to the Boat building yard on the waterfront. Enter the house next door. Steal the pie from the cupboard on the ground floor. Return it to Toby.

Cleaning up the streets: Bring a prostitute to Toby. Find a prostitute and when she asks if you want to have a good time, give her the thumbs up expression. She will follow you. Lead her back to Toby. He will ask you to leave so he can focus on cleansing her.

After these tasks, you will have an opportunity to learn more about Toby. Follow the breadcrumbs and talk to James. He will tell you that Toby has been playing you and everyone wants him gone.

Return to Toby's house and knock until he answers. You have two options to complete the quest: scare him out of town using scary expressions until he runs off, or kill him.